NSW planning resource · LEC Class 1 submission

Appealing a development application refusal in NSW

A Class 1 appeal in the Land and Environment Court is a fresh hearing on the planning merits, not a review of whether the council was reasonable. Applicants hold the right; objectors, with one narrow exception, do not. Here is what the deadline actually runs from, what a deemed refusal is worth, and why the cheaper options are usually worth exhausting first.

NSW applicants whose development application has been refused, conditioned in a way they cannot accept, or left undetermined — and objectors checking whether any appeal right exists on their side.

Who can appeal, and who cannot

Section 8.7 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 gives an applicant for development consent who is dissatisfied with the determination of the application by the consent authority the right to appeal to the Land and Environment Court. Because the right attaches to the determination rather than to a refusal, it covers a consent granted on conditions you cannot accept as readily as an outright refusal. Section 8.7(2) extends it further, to a later decision about an aspect of the development that a condition required to be carried out to someone's satisfaction, and to a decision on a matter the authority had to be satisfied of before a deferred commencement consent could operate. It is a Class 1 appeal — the Court's merits jurisdiction — and the Court re-decides the application rather than auditing the council's reasoning.

Objectors are in a very different position. Section 8.8 confines an objector appeal to designated development, and to State significant development that would be designated development but for section 4.10(2), and requires the appellant to have duly made a submission by way of objection during the public exhibition of the application. Section 8.10(3) gives them 28 days after the date the objector is notified of the decision appealed against. For everything outside those categories, a person who objected has no merits appeal in NSW at all.

That asymmetry is worth naming plainly, because it shapes the whole process. An applicant who loses at council has months and a full merits hearing ahead of them. An objector who loses at council has, in almost every case, already had their only say.

The deadline: six months from the portal, not from your letterbox

Section 8.10(1) requires an appeal by a dissatisfied applicant to be made within 6 months after the date the determination is notified or registered on the NSW planning portal. Read that trigger closely, because it is not the one most people assume. The clock does not start when the notice of determination reaches you, or when you open it — it starts when the determination hits the portal. If a notice is slow in the post, or goes to a consultant who is on leave, the six months has already been running. Check the portal record for the determination date and count from that.

Six months is generous compared with most planning deadlines in Australia, and that is deliberate — it leaves room to negotiate with the council, to amend, or to seek a review before committing to litigation. It is not an invitation to drift. Preparing a Class 1 case properly means assembling expert evidence, and the Court's own listing and conciliation timetable then runs for months beyond the filing date, so a project with any commercial urgency should be making the decision in weeks rather than months.

Seeking a review first does not cost you the appeal. Section 8.9A bars an appeal while a Division 8.2 review is on foot — from the lodgement of the request until the determination is confirmed or changed, the period set under section 8.5(1)(b) expires, or you withdraw the request — and section 8.10(4) then requires that period to be disregarded in calculating the appeal window. So the review suspends the right rather than consuming the clock, which is what makes exhausting the cheaper option first a safe sequence rather than a gamble.

Note the contrast with the objector's period under section 8.10(3): the applicant's runs from the portal, while the objector's 28 days runs from the date that objector is notified of the decision. On the same determination, the two parties count from different events on very different scales.

Deemed refusal — an appeal right that arrives by the calendar

An application does not have to be refused to be appealable. Under section 8.11(1) an application for development consent — or for the modification of one — that the consent authority has not determined within the period prescribed by the regulations is taken, for the purposes of the appeal provisions only, to have been determined by refusing consent when that period ends, and the applicant may appeal that deemed refusal. The section itself does not set the period; it defers to the regulations, which prescribe 40 days for an ordinary development application, 60 days for designated development, integrated development other than Class 1 aquaculture and development requiring concurrence, and 90 days for State significant development.

This appeal has no deadline. Section 8.10(2) lets an applicant bring it at any time after the prescribed period expires and before the consent authority determines the application — the six months in section 8.10(1) applies to an appeal against an actual determination, not to a deemed refusal. The window closes not by the calendar but by the council finally deciding. And a late decision does not kill an appeal already on foot: under section 8.11(3) the determination does not affect the appeal's continuation, and section 8.11(4) lets the authority have the appeal withdrawn only with the applicant's consent and without prejudice to costs.

The arithmetic is where this goes wrong. The period starts on the day the application is lodged, but it is increased by any days the public exhibition runs beyond the statutory minimum, and it ceases to run entirely while a request for additional information made within 25 days of lodgement remains outstanding. A council that appears to be 90 days into a 40-day clock is very often not late at all. Work out where the clock actually stands before relying on a deemed refusal, because an appeal brought on a deemed refusal that has not happened fails on that point alone.

Where the clock genuinely has run out, the deemed refusal is a real tactical option: it gives a stalled application a forum and a timetable, and many such appeals resolve by agreement once the council has to put its position in writing.

What to try before filing

A Class 1 appeal is expensive and slow relative to the alternatives, and most refusals are not best answered with one. Read the notice of determination closely: the reasons for refusal are the council's statement of what is wrong, and a large proportion of them identify specific, addressable deficiencies rather than an in-principle objection to the proposal. A redesigned application lodged afresh often resolves the matter faster and for a fraction of the cost.

Division 8.2 of the Act allows an applicant to ask the consent authority to review its own determination — decided by the council rather than the Court, and section 8.3(3) lets you amend the proposed development in making the request, which is what makes a review the natural home for a design response to the reasons for refusal. Three limits are worth knowing before you count on it. Section 8.2(2) excludes an application relating to a complying development certificate, designated development or Crown development. Section 8.2(3) allows only one review of a determination. And under section 8.3(2) the request must not be made after the appeal period has expired where no appeal was made, or after the Court has disposed of an appeal — so the review window is bounded by the appeal window, not the other way round.

An appeal earns its cost where the refusal turns on a genuinely arguable planning question, where the council has departed from its own instruments, where a numerical variation under the LEP is in contest, or where the proposal cannot be modified without destroying its economics. Those are merits questions, and the merits forum is the right one for them.

How a Class 1 appeal actually runs

Most Class 1 development appeals pass through a conciliation conference under section 34 of the Land and Environment Court Act 1979 before any hearing. A Commissioner convenes the parties on a without-prejudice basis to see whether the matter can be resolved by agreement, frequently on amended plans, and if agreement is reached the Commissioner can dispose of the proceedings on those terms. A large share of appeals end here rather than at a hearing. Residential development appeals are handled under a distinct process, so confirm which applies to your matter when you file.

The consequence is that the written planning case does its most important work before the hearing, not at it. Going into conciliation with the proposal already tested against the LEP, the DCP and each applicable SEPP — and with the council's reasons for refusal answered one by one — is what lets you negotiate from a position rather than react to one.

If the matter does not settle, it proceeds to a hearing, usually including a view of the site. The Court decides the application on its merits against the instruments as they stand at the time of the hearing, which means instruments amended since lodgement can help or hurt, and amended plans put forward during the appeal are assessed on their own terms.

Real example

Worked example — refused on three grounds, settled on two

A dual occupancy is refused on three grounds: a DCP side setback variation, insufficient private open space, and an unresolved stormwater connection. The applicant has 6 months from receiving the notice. The stormwater ground is engineering, not planning, and can be answered with a design and a letter. The open space ground is met by reconfiguring the ground floor. That leaves the setback, which is a genuine merits question about the DCP control and whether the proposal achieves its objective anyway. Filed as a Class 1 appeal, the matter goes to a section 34 conciliation conference with amended plans resolving two grounds and a planning case addressing the third — which is the shape most of these settle in. Had the council instead simply not determined the application, the deemed refusal would have offered the same forum 40 days after lodgement, extended by any exhibition beyond the minimum and paused by any early request for further information.

The statutory basis

Appeal rights sit in Division 8.3 of Part 8 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW); reviews by the consent authority itself sit in Division 8.2. Section 8.7 gives an applicant dissatisfied with the determination of a development application a right of appeal to the Land and Environment Court, and section 8.7(3) provides that such an appeal on designated development cannot be heard until the objector's period has expired. Section 8.8 gives an objector a right of appeal for designated development, and for State significant development that would be designated development but for section 4.10(2), where the appellant duly made a submission by way of objection during public exhibition. Section 8.11 provides for deemed refusal.

Section 8.10 sets the time limits, and it distinguishes three cases that are often run together. Subsection (1) requires an applicant's appeal against a determination to be made within 6 months after the date the determination is notified or registered on the NSW planning portal. Subsection (2) allows an applicant's appeal against a deemed refusal at any time after the prescribed period expires and before the consent authority determines the application, so that appeal has no end date. Subsection (3) allows an objector's appeal only within 28 days after the date the objector is notified of the decision appealed against. Subsection (4) requires the section 8.9A period to be disregarded in the calculation, and section 8.9A bars an appeal while a Division 8.2 review is on foot — together, a review suspends the appeal right without consuming the appeal period.

Review under Division 8.2 is available to an applicant for the determinations and decisions listed in section 8.2(1), but section 8.2(2) excludes an application relating to a complying development certificate, designated development or Crown development, and section 8.2(3) provides that a determination already reviewed under the Division is not subject to further review. Under section 8.3(2) a review must not be requested after the period for any appeal to the Court has expired where no appeal was made, or after the Court has disposed of an appeal. Section 8.3(3) allows the applicant to amend the proposed development in requesting the review.

The deemed refusal periods come from the Environmental Planning and Assessment Regulation 2021 (NSW): 40 days for an ordinary development application, 60 days for designated development, integrated development other than Class 1 aquaculture and development requiring concurrence, and 90 days for State significant development. The period starts on lodgement, is increased by exhibition beyond the statutory minimum, and ceases to run while a request for additional information made within 25 days of lodgement is outstanding. Conciliation conferences are conducted under section 34 of the Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (NSW).

Sections 8.2, 8.3, 8.7, 8.8, 8.9A, 8.10 and 8.11 were read from the authorised consolidation on legislation.nsw.gov.au on 20 November 2026; the Regulation periods reflect the current version as at 23 October 2026. A deadline is not a thing to take on trust from any website, this one included: check the determination date on the portal record for your own matter, and if the date is close, take advice. The threshold at which a development application is referred to a local planning panel is set administratively rather than by the Act and differs between councils. This page is general information about how appeals work, not advice on a particular application.

Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) s 8.7

An applicant dissatisfied with the determination of a DA may appeal to the Land and Environment Court; s 8.7(3) — such an appeal on designated development cannot be heard until the objector's period expires

Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) s 8.10(1)

Applicant's appeal against a determination — within 6 months after the date the determination is notified or registered on the NSW planning portal

Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) s 8.10(2)

Applicant's appeal against a deemed refusal — at any time after the prescribed period expires and before the application is determined. No end date

Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) ss 8.8, 8.10(3)

Objector appeal — designated development, and SSD that would be designated development but for s 4.10(2); only within 28 days after the objector is notified of the decision

Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) ss 8.9A, 8.10(4)

No appeal while a Division 8.2 review is on foot, and that period is disregarded in calculating the appeal period

Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) ss 8.2, 8.3

Review by the consent authority — excluded for a CDC, designated development and Crown development; no second review; not available once the appeal period has expired or the Court has disposed of an appeal

Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) s 8.11

Deemed refusal once the period prescribed by the regulations ends; a later determination does not affect an appeal already on foot

Environmental Planning and Assessment Regulation 2021 (NSW)

40 / 60 / 90 day prescribed periods; the clock pauses while an early request for further information is outstanding

Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (NSW) s 34

Conciliation conference before a Commissioner — where most Class 1 development appeals are resolved

Frequently asked questions

How long do I have to appeal a DA refusal in NSW?
Six months, and section 8.10(1) runs it from the date the determination is notified or registered on the NSW planning portal — not from the date you received the notice. Check the portal record and count from that date. A deemed refusal is different: section 8.10(2) puts no deadline on that appeal at all. Six months is a long period by planning standards, but preparing a Class 1 case and getting through the Court's timetable takes months of its own, and a review you lodge first suspends the appeal right without consuming the six months.
What is a Class 1 appeal?
A merits appeal in the Land and Environment Court. The Court re-decides the development application against the planning instruments rather than reviewing whether the council acted reasonably, which means new material and amended plans can change the result. Most Class 1 development appeals go to a conciliation conference before any hearing.
What is a deemed refusal, and can I appeal it?
If the consent authority has not determined the application within the period prescribed by the regulations, section 8.11 treats it as refused for appeal purposes and you may appeal. The periods are 40 days for an ordinary DA, 60 for designated, integrated and concurrence development, and 90 for State significant development. The clock starts at lodgement, extends for exhibition beyond the statutory minimum, and stops while a request for further information made within 25 days of lodgement is outstanding — so check where it really stands before filing, because an appeal on a deemed refusal that has not happened fails on that point alone. There is no deadline at the other end: section 8.10(2) lets you appeal at any time until the council actually determines the application.
Can an objector appeal a development consent in NSW?
Only for designated development — or State significant development that would be designated development but for section 4.10(2) — under section 8.8, and only if they duly made a submission by way of objection during the public exhibition. Section 8.10(3) gives them 28 days after the date they are notified of the decision. Note section 8.7(3): where an objector can appeal, your own appeal cannot be heard until their 28 days have run. For every other kind of development, objectors have no merits appeal in NSW — which is why the submission made during exhibition is the decisive step.
Should I appeal or just lodge a new application?
Read the reasons for refusal first. Where they identify specific, addressable deficiencies — a setback, a parking shortfall, a missing report — a redesigned application is usually faster and far cheaper than an appeal. An appeal earns its cost where the refusal rests on a genuinely arguable planning question, where the council has departed from its own instruments, or where the proposal cannot be modified without destroying its economics.
What is a section 34 conciliation conference?
A without-prejudice conference convened by a Commissioner of the Land and Environment Court to see whether the appeal can be resolved by agreement, very often on amended plans. If the parties agree, the Commissioner can dispose of the proceedings on those terms. Most Class 1 development appeals resolve at this stage, which is why the written planning case matters most before the hearing rather than at it.
Can I ask the council to reconsider instead of appealing?
Division 8.2 allows a request that the consent authority review its own determination, and section 8.3(3) lets you amend the proposed development in making it. It is not available for every kind of development: section 8.2(2) excludes a complying development certificate, designated development and Crown development, and section 8.2(3) allows only one review. Under section 8.3(2) the request must not be made once the appeal period has expired with no appeal, or once the Court has disposed of an appeal — so the review window sits inside the appeal window.
Do I need a lawyer and experts for a Class 1 appeal?
You can appear for yourself, but Class 1 is an evidence-based merits jurisdiction and contested appeals usually involve expert planning evidence, often with traffic, heritage, acoustic or arboricultural evidence alongside it. What a written planning case does — whether or not you brief lawyers — is answer each reason for refusal against the instrument it rests on, which is the material both conciliation and a hearing run on.

LEC Class 1 submission — ready when you are

A written planning case for your appeal — the proposal tested against the LEP, the DCP and each applicable SEPP, with the council's reasons for refusal answered one at a time.